The Origins of the Lox Bagel in NYC
The lox bagel is a true New York City classic, deeply rooted in the city’s Jewish immigrant history. It’s origins trace back to the late 19th and early 20th centuries, when Eastern European Jewish immigrants brought their love for bagels and smoked fish to NYC.
Want to go there?
Add the Place of Interest
Create your own itineraries in MyPlan, on the Ylore Travel app.
How Did It Start?
🔹 Bagels – These chewy, boiled-then-baked rings of dough originated in Poland and became a staple for Jewish immigrants in New York.
🔹 Lox – Derived from the Yiddish word laks (meaning salmon), lox is cured salmon, a delicacy with roots in Eastern Europe.
🔹 Cream Cheese – This was an American addition, first produced in the late 1800s in upstate New York, making it the perfect creamy pairing for salty lox.
By the early 20th century, bagel shops and appetizing stores (like the famous Russ & Daughters, opened in 1914) were serving bagels with lox and schmear (cream cheese), and the combination became an NYC staple.
Delicatessen Vs Appetizing Store
In your travels you might notice that places like Katz’s Delicatessen and Russ & Daughters serve different types of foods, but they both seems to be deli’s. The answer is, it comes down to Jewish religion.
Key Differences
- Appetizing stores = dairy & fish (no meat)
- Jewish delis = meat (no dairy)
- In kosher tradition, you wouldn’t find a bagel with lox and cream cheese in a Jewish deli, just as you wouldn’t find a pastrami sandwich in an appetizing store.
181 E Houston St, Manhattan, New York County, 10002203 E Houston St, Manhattan, New York County, 10002What’s in a Classic Lox Bagel?
🥯 Bagel – Traditionally plain, sesame, or everything, sliced and toasted (or fresh).
🧀 Cream Cheese – Smooth, tangy, and essential for balancing flavors.
🐟 Lox – Cured (but not smoked) salmon, known for its silky texture and salty, briny taste.
🧅 Red Onion – Adds a sharp, crisp bite.
🍅 Tomato – Fresh, juicy slices for contrast.
🥒 Capers – Tiny, tangy, and packed with flavor.
Why Is It So Loved?
✅ Perfect Balance of Flavors – The mix of chewy bagel, salty lox, creamy cheese, and fresh toppings creates a legendary taste experience.
✅ New York Tradition – It’s a cultural institution, served in iconic delis and bagel shops across the city.
✅ All-Day Appeal – Whether it’s breakfast, brunch, or a late-night bite, a lox bagel always hits the spot.
Some time back I was in Tompkins Square Park in the East Village, and more than three quarters of the people around me were munching on Lox Bagels. Sadly I skipped the memo that day, but I made up for it some time later.
Where to Try It in NYC
If you’re in New York, some of the best spots for an authentic lox bagel include:
📍 Russ & Daughters (Lower East Side) – The gold standard since 1914.
📍 Ess-a-Bagel (Midtown) – Huge, chewy bagels loaded with fresh lox.
📍 Barney Greengrass (Upper West Side) – A historic Jewish deli with top-notch salmon.
Final Thoughts
A lox bagel isn’t just food, it’s an NYC experience, a bite of history. Want to be a New Yorker, even for a few moments? This is your chance.
Discover More with Ylore
Explore New York and surrounds like never before with our immersive, multimedia self-guided tours. Dive deeper into the stories of the people and places that make the city a world-renowned destination.
With Ylore Travel, you’ll also enjoy:
- Pop-Up Tour Points featuring local insights and must-try food spots
- Hidden Gems showcasing unique activities and secret locations
- Travel Tips & Insights to make your journey smoother and more enriching
Start your adventures today here or browse for ideas on where to go an what to do here.
Follow Us
Download the Ylore Travel app
Brett Williams
Brett Williams is the founder of Ylore Travel, a platform dedicated to making self-guided travel accessible to adventurers worldwide. With experience exploring over 50 countries and living in four, Brett’s passion for discovering new places and immersing himself in diverse cultures inspired the creation of Ylore Travel. Based in New York, he continues to seek out unique experiences and empower others to explore the world at their own pace.